SpeediDashSpeediDash

Why Your Speedometer Reads Higher Than GPS

Your speedometer reads higher than GPS because it's meant to. The rules most countries use say a speedometer may show more than your true speed but never less, so car makers set them to read a little high. If your dashboard says 100 and a GPS speedometer says 95, the GPS number is almost certainly closer to the truth.

The rule: read high, never low

Speedometer accuracy is set by UN Regulation No. 39, which applies in the EU, the UK and the many other countries that follow UN vehicle rules. Its key clause is short. The speed shown must never be less than the true speed, and when a new model is approved it may be no more than 10% of the true speed plus 4 km/h above it:

0 ≤ shown speed − true speed ≤ 0.1 × true speed + 4 km/h

Here's what that allows at common speeds:

True speedLowest legal readingHighest legal reading
30 km/h30 km/h37 km/h
50 km/h50 km/h59 km/h
80 km/h80 km/h92 km/h
100 km/h100 km/h114 km/h
120 km/h120 km/h136 km/h

A speedometer that read low could earn a driver a speeding fine through no fault of their own. So manufacturers aim a few percent high, which keeps every car inside the rule with any approved tyre, at any load, on any day. India's speedometer standard, IS 11827:2008 from the Bureau of Indian Standards, sets exactly the same rule and the same formula.

Why the gap grows as you go faster

Most of a speedometer's error is a percentage of your speed, so the gap in km/h widens as you speed up. A car that reads 3% high shows 51.5 at a true 50, but 103 at a true 100 and almost 124 at a true 120. A difference of 1 or 2 km/h in town and 4 or 5 on the highway is normal and doesn't mean anything is broken.

What changes your speedometer's error

  • Tyre size. A speedometer works out your speed from how fast the wheels or gearbox turn. Fit wheels and tyres with a bigger overall diameter and each turn covers more road, so the car now reads lower than before. A tyre 3% larger can wipe out a typical built-in margin. Smaller tyres do the opposite.
  • Tyre wear. A new car tyre has about 8 mm of tread. Worn down to 2 mm, its diameter shrinks by around 12 mm, roughly 2% on a typical car tyre, so the reading creeps up as the tread wears.
  • Pressure and load. An under-inflated or heavily loaded tyre rolls a slightly smaller circle and nudges the reading up.
  • Gearing on motorcycles. If a bike's speed sensor reads from the gearbox, a new sprocket changes the ratio between what the sensor sees and how fast the wheel turns.

How to test your own speedometer

  1. Ask a passenger to hold the phone, or fix it in a holder before you set off.
  2. Open the speedometer accuracy test and wait for "GPS locked".
  3. On a straight, flat, open road, hold a steady 60 on the dashboard for ten seconds and note the GPS speed.
  4. Repeat at 100, or at the highest legal speed for that road.

Then work out the error: (dashboard − GPS) ÷ GPS × 100. A dashboard 100 against a GPS 95 means your speedometer reads 5.3% high.

Is GPS always right?

No measurement is perfect, but at a steady speed on an open road GPS is the better reference. Phones calculate speed from the Doppler shift of satellite signals and are typically within 1 to 2 km/h under open sky. Wait for the number to settle after you accelerate, and avoid tall buildings, tunnels and heavy tree cover. How accurate is a GPS speedometer? explains when the reading can wander.

What about the odometer?

The odometer counts the same wheel turns, but it doesn't need a safety margin. On many cars it's closer to the truth than the speedometer, because the extra margin is often added to the speed display only. If you log mileage for work, check it once against the GPS distance of a long, simple trip.

When to worry

A speedometer that reads a few percent high is normal and works in your favour with speed limits. Get your car checked if:

  • it reads lower than GPS at a steady speed,
  • the error suddenly changes when nothing else has, or
  • the needle flickers, jumps or drops to zero while you're moving.

The usual causes are the wrong tyre size, a failing wheel-speed sensor or a fault in the instrument cluster.

Sources

Test your speedometer against GPS

Open Speedometer Accuracy Test

Keep reading